The rise in bilateral mastectomies: Evidence, ethics, and physician's role

The rise in bilateral mastectomies: Evidence, ethics, and physician's role

The Breast
Yang YT et al

This viewpoint reviews double mastectomies' trend, medical evidence and ethical considerations, as well as the role of the physician in counseling the patient. It concludes that physicians should encourage patients to pursue alternative preventive measures, and promote bilateral mastectomies only for high-risk patients for whom the potential benefits of the surgery are sufficient to justify the surgery's increased risks. 

No reduction in death rate is seen with bilateral mastectomy

No reduction in death rate is seen with bilateral mastectomy. BMJ 2014; 349.

McCarthy, M.

http://www.bmj.com/content/349/bmj.g5402?rss=1&variant=short&hwoasp=authn%3A1409906788%3A4044144%3A3266341273%3A0%3A0%3A6BZxAKWi6ImzkhkTN57Ukg%3D%3D

Increasing numbers of US women with breast cancer are opting for double mastectomies, but the procedure is not associated with a lower 10 year mortality than breast conserving surgery with radiation, a study has found. The study was reported in the 3 September issue of JAMA. Allison W Kurian, of Stanford University School of Medicine in California, and colleagues, accessed data that had been collected from 1998 to 2011 on 189 734 women who had new diagnoses of early, unilateral breast cancer at stages 0-III. The data came from the California Cancer Registry—a population based registry that captures information on about 99% of the state’s breast cancer cases—and the median length of follow-up for patients was 89.1 months.